Maeve recently spent a week with us in New Jersey to attend art camp with Nora at the Visual Arts Center. The girls share many things in addition to the special relationship that only cousins have. One of those things is a deep love of ice cream. I proposed that they taste-test ice cream at various locations in the area during the week and I would publish the results on my new blog. Though pre-adolescent, they found nothing to object to in this plan!
Ice cream was evaluated for creaminess, cone, texture, sweetness and toppings and rated based on the following scale:
1=marvelous
2=great
3=good
4=okay
5=poor
Our first stop was the new Home Plate Dairy on Route 57 in Stewartsville (former home of Custard's Last Stand, an entrepreneurial ice cream establishment that switched to deer processing in the winter months). Home Plate came highly recommended by Rachel and Gardner but could it pass muster with true experts in the field? Nora had a chocolate and vanilla twist in a wafer cone and Maeve had a twist in a waffle cone with chocolate crunch sprinkles. It became immediately clear that these were some tough critics. The overall score for Home Plate was only a 2.8/good with the highest marks a pair of twos for texture and sweetness.
The next stop was Ricky's on Springfield Avenue in Summit where Nora sampled Cake Batter ice cream in a cup with M&Ms, whipped cream and chocolate syrup and Maeve went for Rocky Road with whipped cream in a waffle cone. Ricky's has a free toppings bar and clearly they have cornered that market earning them a top score of 1/marvelous for both toppings and sweetness. "Okay" marks for the cone brought the total score to 2.2/great, sadly shy of the coveted "marvelous" ranking.
The last stop in Part 1 of this exhaustive survey was the one and only MF or Magic Fountain, also in Summit on Morris Avenue. Here Nora and Maeve both ordered Cookie Dough with Nora opting for a wafer cone and Maeve for a sugar cone. Our critics gave MF respectable marks of 2/great for creaminess, texture and sweetness but it did not excel in any areas and suffered from the same inferior cones as Home Plate and Ricky's. The overall score? A 2.5 bringing MF in squarely in between Ricky's and Home Plate.
The results:
1st place- Ricky's for its marvelous toppings and unparalleled sweetness
2nd place- Magic Fountain which is just plain great if you ignore the cones
3rd place- Home Plate Dairy just couldn't compete
Stay tuned as the girls continue their efforts and strive to maintain this rigorous schedule of tastings in the Official Ice Cream Survey Part II: Maine and the Official Ice Cream Survey Part III: The Hamptons!
Posts
No comments:
Post a Comment